A response to "Pulpit rotation" Case by case: Case by case

Read Ellen Blue's fictional narrative first.

We get a glimpse here of a pastor who is doing many things well. She is a leader willing to learn the rhythms of a farming community and the nature of the people in it. She has a passion for meeting local needs and for collaborating with other churches. It is a testament to her leadership that her congregation has accepted its first female pastor with only a “modicum of hesitation.” We can assume that congregation members are hearing others in town express reservations about women in ministry, but they are choosing to stand with her.

Though Madeline is supported by her congregation in important ways, some issues of communication need attention. In order to avoid conflict and perhaps to spare Madeline’s feelings, lay leaders have not been direct with her. They have discussed Madeline’s role in the Thanksgiving service among themselves and made decisions about their participation—but without getting her input.