Muslims call new religious freedom appointee a 'puppet' for Islam foes

c. 2012 Religion News Service
WASHINGTON (RNS) One of two new members of the U.S. Commission on International
Religious Freedom has Muslim civil rights groups crying foul.

Zuhdi Jasser, who lauded a controversial New York City police surveillance
program that targeted Muslims and helped lead the opposition to an Islamic
cultural center near Ground Zero, has been appointed to the commission, which
advises the president, Congress and State Department on religious rights abuses
internationally.

"It would have been better to appoint someone who has some measure of
credibility with Muslim Americans," said Ibrahim Hooper, spokesman for the
Council on American-Islamic Relations.

"He has long been viewed by American Muslims and the colleagues in the civil
liberties community as a mere sock puppet for Islam haters and an enabler of
Islamophobia."

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., appointed Jasser and House
Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, appointed Robert P. George, a philosophy professor
at Princeton University and top adviser to the U.S. Catholic bishops.

Democrats appoint five of the commission's nine members, because they are
the party in the White House; the other four are appointed by Republicans. With
the Jasser and George appointments, three commission spots remain vacant.

Jasser, an activist and cardiologist from Phoenix, addressed the first in a
series of hearings last year called by the House Homeland Security Committee to
investigate the threat of homegrown terrorism.

Jasser's group, the American Islamic Forum for Democracy, has called the
leadership of most established U.S. Muslim groups "malignant" and accused them
of preaching a form of "political Islam."

Jasser won praise from conservatives for his willingness to testify about
his co-religionists, but gained the ire of Muslims who said he fuels anti-Muslim
prejudice.

George, well respected in conservative circles, comes to the commission with
a less controversial profile.

A political philosopher and constitutional scholar, he is a board member of
the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, a Washington-based non-profit that has
provided much of the legal defense for churches in high-profile religious
freedom cases.

Many Catholic bishops rely on George as "a touchstone" and consider him "the
pre-eminent Catholic intellectual," Bishop John Myers of Newark, N.J. told the
New York Times in 2009.

Most recently, George has helped rally opposition to President Obama's
contraception mandate. He is also one of the principle drafters of the
"Manhattan Declaration," a 2009 conservative manifesto that encouraged
Christians to resist abortion, same-sex marriage and threats to "religious
liberty."