Chaplains say Navy wedding policy confuses a fraught debate

May 10, 2011

WASHINGTON (RNS) A recent Navy memo that would permit military chaplains
to officiate at same-sex marriage ceremonies upon repeal of the
military's Don't Ask/Don't Tell policy is creating tension amid an
already fractious debate.

"It is absolutely deplorable," said the Rev. Billy Baugham,
executive director of the International Conference of Evangelical
Chaplain Endorsers. "It is a total surprise to us in the sense that we
did not know it would really come to this."

The chief of Navy chaplains announced in an April 13 memo that
training materials for the expected repeal have been changed to allow
chaplains to officiate at some same-sex ceremonies.

"If the base is located in a state where same-sex marriage is legal,
then base facilities may normally be used to celebrate the marriage,"
wrote Navy Rear Adm. Mark Tidd, who added that a chaplain "may
officiate" if participation is "consistent with the tenets of his or her
religious organization."

Baugham said leaders of his small, conservative Christian
organization will likely assess if they want to continue sending
chaplains to the Navy under such a policy, but he expects chaplains
already in the services to remain.

Chaplain Mark Schreiber, director of the Lutheran Church-Missouri
Synod's military ministry, said chaplains who disagree with the policy
will not be forced to officiate at same-sex weddings and he expects "no
mass exodus."

Even so, he has registered his disapproval with the chief of
chaplains, and said the policy seems to violate the federal Defense of
Marriage Act, which defines marriage as between one man and one woman.

"Base property ... is under federal mandate and DOMA has not been
repealed," he said. "Now we're pitting one entity against the other."

Pentagon spokeswoman Eileen Lainez disagreed, telling the Navy
Times: "DOMA does not limit the type of religious ceremonies a chaplain
may perform in a chapel on a military installation. Chaplains are
authorized to perform religious ceremonies consistent with the practices
of the chaplain's faith group in chapels on military installations."

Other chaplain endorsers who oppose the new weddings policy hope
political pressure may prompt the Navy to reverse course.

Republican critics of both the Navy's action and the Don't Ask/Don't
Tell repeal are expected to introduce amendments Wednesday (May 11) to
the defense authorization bill when it is considered by the House Armed
Services Committee.

Aaron Belkin, director of the Palm Center, which has studied gays in
the military, hopes the Republican efforts will fail.

"Republican opposition is not about doing what's best for the
military," said Belkin, whose think tank is based at the University of
California, Los Angeles. "It is the Navy's, and not the House
Republicans', policy that shows deference to the religious beliefs of
the clergy."